Who is the happy Warrior?
Who is he
That every man in arms should wish to be?
asked William Wordsworth, knowing nothing of war but certain, nevertheless, of what the answer should be, while
Happy are men who yet before they are killed
Can let their veins run cold
replied Wilfred Owen a century and more later, knowing too much about war, nevertheless, to be altogether sure that he was right
No uncertainty in Shelley's mind when he wrote in his famous Defence of Poetry that the state of mind produced by delicate sensibility and enlarged imagination is at war with every base desire.
Which is fair enough except that Shelley had not been to war either. It was left to Owen to decide whether sensibility in war was a blessing or a curse.
Was he referring to INSENSIBILITY when he wrote from Ripon on 21 April 1918 to his cousin Leslie Gunston:
I have written, I think, two poems: one an Ode which, considering my tuneless tendencies, may be called dam (sic) good….
Tuneless tendencies might fit because the poem is not notable for its melodic harmonies. What rhythm it has is broken, the metre irregular as is its structure - 6 stanzas of 11,9,12,9,10,10 lines having irregular length. It is not a poem of any great beauty.
A remarkable feature, however, is the elaborate use of pararhymes. The poem is almost top heavy with them, and they effectively produce a downbeat feeling that recalls Mathew Arnold.
Stanza 1 opens with Owen apparently propounding his opinion that the fighting man is better off having no sympathetic imagination, ("fleers" = mocks).
Lines 4 & 5's horrifying image
Or makes their feet
Sore on the alleys cobbled with their brothers
echoes a remark Owen made to his sister Mary in March 1918 -
They are dying again at Beaumont Hamel which already in 1916 was cobbled with skulls… (The German breakthrough of March 1918 when the British Army "had its back to the wall" being pushed back some 40 miles from St.Quentin to Villers Bretonneux. - See Owen web site Lancs. Fusiliers at Hawthorn Redoubt and Edmund Blunden web site for views of Beaumont Hamel.)
How easily then might an excess of imagination play havoc with men's nerves.
Lines 7 - 8 have
But they are troops who fade, not flowers
For poets' tearful fooling:
The troops are those who matter, those same heroes of whom Owen tells us in his Preface, English Poetry "is not yet fit to speak"; the same men who are thought of merely as " gaps for filling" (9), men "who might have fought longer" (10-11), bitter words that lead to an end-of-stanza dying fall like that in EXPOSURE ("But nothing happens")
……but no one bothers.
And some cease feeling (12)
Well, some do. For the rest,
The tease and doubt of shelling (15)
means the grim reality of wondering who'll cop it next. It's
Chance's strange arithmetic (16)
Not mathematical probability that operates here, yet even that
"comes simpler" (17) than gauging the final reckoning, for how can that be quantified?
The word "happy" crops up again. If to lose one's imagination (19) implies having had one in the first place, battle seems an unlikely occasion for its surrender. Owen suggests that with imagination "lost", physical burdens may be unavoidable but that the men's "spirit drags no pack" (21), that "having seen all things red" (23) spilled blood no longer has power to derange. Hearts remain unaffected, small-drawn" (27). Having seen men die "in some scorching cautery of battle" (28) minds are thenceforth immunised against further hauntings.
We may think, tell that to the Mental Cases.
The expression "soldier home" (31) must mean repatriate not one who has not gone out. How then can he be "with not a notion" of the business of war. Who is the lad "whose mind was never trained" (34)? Trained in what? In sensibility?
Now comes the turning point. So far it has all been about our Happy Warrior. Suddenly in mid-stanza pronouns change from "they" to "we" and Owen slips quietly into another gear. We don't sing, we "march taciturn". (37), we who are fully conscious of the dusk and
The long, forlorn, relentless trend
From larger day to huger night. (38-9),
we for whom insensibility is not an option.
Stanza 5 continues in the first person (we) (40-3) but then reverts to third (he, his). Seemingly Owen is arguing a dichotomy between us (the wise) whose thoughts of guilt
Blood over all our soul, (40-1)
and the insensible ones, "not vital overmuch" (44), not even "mortal overmuch". (45) not sad, proud, curious. In other words, not much anything really. If this comes from losing imagination it's hard to see where happiness comes in. Perhaps after all we should not see the two states as polarised. Does the clue come in lines 42-3?
How should we see our task
But through his blunt and lashless eyes?
How, asks Owen, can we poets do our job properly and rationally without curbing our imagination? Against this, without a measure of sensibility, mind and spirit die. So what's the solution?
In stanza 6 Owen seems to confute the arguments he started out with, that the soldier should abandon feeling in the interests of keeping sane.
Dullness best solves
The tease and doubt of shelling he'd written in stanza 1 while in stanza 6 we read
But cursed are dullards whom no cannon stuns (50)
Can Owen have it both ways? Well, yes if we see the irony in that first quotation, see it not as advice but as a wry observation. The tone of the last stanza suggests that the kind of happiness achieved through suppressing feeling is achieved only at a price.
By choice they made themselves immune
we're told. So does he condemn them? No, for he understands why they choose thus. He's told us in (42-3) that the poet must look at these issues through the soldiers' eyes. Yet to discard pity or whatever hurts or gives cause for lament, to whatever shares "the eternal reciprocity of tears" (and I take the "whatever" to mean an entity or quality beyond ourselves) diminishes us all.
Whether "eternal" simply signifies "timeless" or as containing a spiritual dimension is up to us to decide.
Copyright Kenneth Simcox, 2000
Students can join the Wilfred Owen Association from just £8!
Next: InspectionPrevious: I Am The Ghost Of Shadwell Stair Back to poetry critiques
A scan of a final draft of Anthem for Doomed Youth by Wilfred Owen penned SlideShare.
Poetry Analysis Year QCE English Thinkswap Wilfred Owen Speech Poetry.
Wilfred Owen Spring Offensive Annotation YouTube.
Wilfred Owen Poems Insensibility Summary and Analysis Thinkswap.
On My Songs The Wilfred Owen Association Thinkswap.
A scan of a final draft of Anthem for Doomed Youth by Wilfred Owen penned Essay.
War poetry analysis of Wilfred Owen s Dulce et Decorum est .
Dulce et Decorum Est Imagery symbolism and themes Wilfred Free Examples Essay And Paper Joncourt France where Wilfred Owen fought .
wilfred owen essay YouTube.
War imminent US Poster Michael P Whelan Teachit.
The Dead Beat Wikipedia World News A new heaven wilfred owen analysis essay Spa Peterborough Related GCSE Wilfred Owen essays.
Insensibility by wilfred owen essay outline Free Examples Essay And Paper Anthem for Doomed Youth Wilfred Owen audiobook.
Wilfred Owen Exposure Pinterest.
Analysis of by Wilfred Owen AbeBooks.
Florian wolschin dissertation Valam Foods P Ltd Photo of Wilfred Owen.
Wilfred Owen futility Annotation Essay Notice that they are subverted in Owen s poem replaced with heartlessness and lack of human compassion .
Insensibility wilfred owen essay format Norman maccaig brooklyn cop essay format.
Picture Crossref it info.
Wilfred Owen futility Annotation Mini Store GradeSaver.
Auto Age Standoff Provides A Car Combat Comeback A TLS Interview.
Introduction to A Close Study of Wilfred Owen Module B.
Wilfred Owen Greatest War Poet in the English Language.
Wilfred Owen Exposure Essay.
Essays on wilfred owen poems Insensibility Smash The HSC Insensibility wilfred owen essay format Face benjamin zephaniah essay.
Wild with All Regrets Synopsis and commentary Wilfred Owen WWI platoon parade.
Poetry Analysis Year QCE English Thinkswap English course booklet.
Wilfred Owen Greatest War Poet in the English Language Context of Owen s poetry.
Insensibility Imagery symbolism and themes Wilfred Owen critically evalute Insensibility of Wilfred Owen.
Kate chopin research paper Picture.
Anthem for Doomed Youth Wilfred Owen audiobook AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.
Florian wolschin dissertation Valam Foods P Ltd BBC How to Write a Literature Essay Using Wilfred Owen s Poetry.
Insensibility Wilfred Owen Pinterest.
WW I Archives BOOK OF DAYS TALES World News.
pat barker wilfred owen search results Teachit YouTube.
Wilfred Owen s War Propaganda Poems World News.
Wild with All Regrets Synopsis and commentary Wilfred Owen critically evalute Insensibility of Wilfred Owen.
pat barker wilfred owen search results Teachit.
War Poetry Essay Scaffold by MissP Teaching Resources TES.
The Next War HSC Standard English YouTube Sambre Canal where Wilfred Owen died.
Kate chopin research paper.
Dulce Et Decorum Est it is sweet and right by Wilfred Owen The poem is meant as a condemnation of war In November Owen was .
Wilfred Owen Biography SlideShare.
Final notes on Insensibility YouTube.
BHS HSC STANDARD ENGLISH coolstuffschool.
Wilfred Owen Essay english cc Carpinteria Rural Friedrich.
Insensibility Smash The HSC Wikipedia.
Poetry Analysis Year QCE English Thinkswap Teachit.
Insensibility Wilfred Owen.
Poetry Analysis Year QCE English Thinkswap Bridal Dresses model essay Model essay letter of complaint xbox one Essay on labour day in urdu.
learn english essay writing the important of learning english free Wilfred Owen Exposure Essay.
wilfred owen poem analysis essay Brotherhood.
learn english essay writing essay on english essay format for Wikipedia toefl essay types amp essay patterns get your highest score about fifty sample toefl essays written.
Soldiers leaving for war.
Miners Synopsis and commentary Wilfred Owen selected poems .
WW I Archives BOOK OF DAYS TALES Brotherhood.
critical analysis of a case study dravit si.
Wilfred Owen Essays AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.
Image of London circa .
Wilfred Owen Exposure Essay.
critical analysis of a case study Modernism Lab Yale University.
Soldiers leaving for war SlideShare.
wilfred owen essay.
Introduction Wilfred Owen selected poems Study Guide from Free Examples Essay And Paper.
Essay questions on wilfred owen AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.
Poems not Collected by Wilfred Owen Siegfried Sassoon First Wikipedia.
Insensibility Wilfred Owen Anthem for Doomed Youth Wilfred Owen audiobook.
Insensibility Part YouTube.
Disabled Synopsis and commentary Wilfred Owen selected poems Insensibility Smash The HSC.
critically evalute Insensibility of Wilfred Owen Wikipedia.
Insensibility wilfred owen essay format Norman maccaig brooklyn cop essay format Caliban s speech analysis essay FC .
Kickstarter Supplementals Done Right With Night in the Woods Two Insensibility Smash The HSC.
Insensibility Smash The HSC.
Insensibility wilfred owen poem analysis essay.
Anthem for doomed youth by wilfred owen essay Synthesis Essay Introduction Example Starting A Business Essay .
Essays on wilfred owen poems.
Wilfred Owen Poems Insensibility Summary and Analysis Crossref it info Auto Age Standoff Provides A Car Combat Comeback A TLS Interview.
critical analysis of a case study Picture.
Postcard of WWI hospital ward AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.
The Dead Beat Wikipedia Two Left Sticks Insensibility Wilfred Owen Free Essays StudyMode.
Topics this document covers Wilfred Owen Insensibility Owen Nature Wilfred Owen selected poems Study Guide from Crossref it .
Portrait of Wilfred Owen.
Soldiers leaving for war.
Soldiers leaving for war YouTube.
Dulce Et Decorum Est Gcse Essay Preview.
The Next War HSC Standard English How to Write a Literature Essay Using Wilfred Owen s Poetry.
Wilfred owen dulce et decorum essay Research paper Academic .
WILFRED OWEN INSENSIBILITY ESSAY netzari info Wilfred Owen s grave Attribution Hector Creative Commons licence.
Insensibility Wilfred Owen AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News.
Wilfred Owen Essays.
learn english essay writing the important of learning english free Wilfred Owen Poems Analysis.
Wilfred Owen Exposure.
Futility Wilfred Owen Wilfred Owen was born in Shropshire to an Smash The HSC.
owen essay In hindsight definition example essay FC .
Futility by Wilfred Owen .
Disabled Wilfred Owen Essay Outline Essay for you AppTiled com Unique App Finder Engine Latest Reviews Market News Kate chopin the awakening essays Wilfred owen insensibility essay writing Kate chopin the awakening essays Wilfred.